Choosing between buying an apartment vs buying a house is honestly one of the biggest decisions you’ll face. In Melbourne’s market right now, this choice affects everything. Your lifestyle, sure. But also your finances and how much wealth you actually build over the next 10, 20, or 30 years.

The numbers? Median house prices sit at $956,305. Apartments come in at $622,939. That’s quite a gap. But what are you actually getting for that difference?

The answer lies in understanding Melbourne’s property market.

Key Takeaways:

Houses in Melbourne deliver stronger capital growth (2.1% annually) while apartments have barely moved (−0.2%), making houses the smarter long-term wealth play.
Lower apartment prices look tempting upfront, but body corporate fees of $3k-$10k+ yearly eat into returns without building any equity for you.
Melbourne’s median house price is at its lowest relative to Sydney in 40+ years, and with 132,500 new residents arriving in 2024, that gap won’t last forever.

Estimated reading time: 5-6 minutes.

Understanding Melbourne’s Property Market

Melbourne’s property landscape has shifted into recovery mode after a tough couple of years. Dwelling values are climbing 1.4% annually. Not exactly the best, but still a clear improvement from the decline we saw previously.

The apartments vs houses investment split depicts the real story, though. Houses gained 2.1% annually, while apartments slipped 0.2% over the same timeframe.

Here’s something that also caught our attention: Melbourne’s median house price is now equivalent to 57% of Sydney’s median price. That’s the lowest it’s been in over forty years. For anyone who understands property cycles, that kind of gap doesn’t last forever.

And there’s more fuel behind this momentum. Victoria brought in 132,500 new residents in 2024, mostly from overseas. With population growth showing no signs of slowing, demand for housing isn’t going anywhere.

Buying an Apartment vs Buying a House: Key Differences

The decision to buy an apartment vs a house goes far beyond price. Each property type serves different purposes and delivers very different outcomes over time.

At InvestorKit, we focus exclusively on houses – not because we have anything against apartments, but because experience and data have shown us that houses consistently outperform apartments when it comes to capital growth and long-term wealth creation.

Cost and Affordability

The entry price difference when buying an apartment in Melbourne vs buying a house in Melbourne is obvious. Apartments are roughly 35% cheaper to get into, and lower entry costs sound great until you dig into what you’re actually buying.

With houses, you own land. They’re not making any more of it. That land appreciates whether your building does or not. With apartments, you’re splitting land value between everyone in the building. Your portion is comparatively smaller.

Then you’ve got ongoing costs. Body corporate fees for apartments run anywhere from $3,000 to over $10,000 every year. Forever. That money covers building maintenance, insurance, and shared amenities. But it never builds equity for you. Houses need maintenance, and we’re not going to pretend they don’t.

The difference? You decide when to spend and how much. Plus, any improvements you make add value to your asset.

Lifestyle Considerations

Apartments win on lifestyle in the short run. Many are situated right in inner-city spots close to work, restaurants, everything. Young professionals love this. Downsizers too. Minimal maintenance, lock the door and leave for weeks.

Houses offer something else entirely. Space. Privacy. Control over your own place. Freedom to paint your door any colour of your choosing or whether you can have a dog.

For families, especially, buying a house in Melbourne means actual yards for kids and pets, parking for multiple cars, and the option to extend or renovate the layout to your liking.

Apartment vs House Investment: Long-Term Potential

This is where it gets crucial if your goal is financial freedom and long-term wealth creation.

The historical data doesn’t lie. Houses deliver better capital growth than apartments, period. Houses in Melbourne rose 2.5% annually, while units barely budged at 0.2% recently.

The apartment vs house investment choice really comes down to supply and demand basics. Apartments can be built upward indefinitely in most locations. Keep adding supply, prices stay flat or even drop.

Houses in established suburbs with limited land? Natural supply constraints push values up over time. Oxford Economics is predicting Melbourne house prices will jump 21% by mid-2027.

And rental yields only tell part of the picture. Sure, apartments might give you 4-5% yields versus 3-3.5% for houses. But think about it – what matters more? A house that doubles in value over 15 years and gives you way better returns, or an apartment with slightly higher rent but not any major price growth.

Pros and Cons of Buying an Apartment vs a House

Now, let’s break down the pros and cons of buying an apartment vs a house so you know exactly what you’re getting into.

Pros of buying an apartment:

Lower entry prices
Less maintenance hassle
Central locations
Lock-and-leave convenience
Modern amenities like gyms and pools

Cons of buying an apartment:

Limited capital growth
Endless body corporate fees
Less privacy – your neighbours might be able to hear you
Building defect risks
Oversupply problems in some areas
Restrictions on renovations

Pros of buying a house:

Strong capital growth over time
Actual land ownership
Total renovation flexibility
Privacy and space for families
No body corporate fees to affect your returns
Complete control over your asset

Cons of buying a house:

Higher purchase price upfront
Increased maintenance responsibility
Potentially longer commutes if you want family-friendly suburbs
Higher council rates

Tips for Making the Right Decision

Define Your Priorities

Get clear on what you actually want. Lifestyle or investment returns? If you’re buying an apartment in Melbourne because you want walkability and zero lawn care, that’s completely fine. Just understand you’re probably sacrificing capital appreciation. And if wealth building is your goal, houses in growth suburbs might be the better option.

Timeframe matters too. Under 5 years exposes you to market swings and transaction costs. Over 10+ years allows capital growth to compound.

So, when you buy a house or apartment, match your property choice to your timeline and financial objectives.

Factor in Melbourne-Specific Considerations

Melbourne’s market has quirks that smart investors use to their advantage. The auction culture here means several quality houses sell off-market before public listings. You need specialists who can access those opportunities.

Next, suburb growth trends matter too. Areas like Frankston and Moonee Ponds have delivered 6-9% annual growth – significantly better than the market average. These suburbs have strong infrastructure, great amenities, and a limited supply, driving sustained price growth.

Infrastructure investment is also reshaping Melbourne’s outer suburbs. New rail lines, schools, and commercial development create growth corridors. Intelligent investors identify these areas early on.

Consult a Buyer’s Agent

Trying to navigate Melbourne’s property market all by yourself is tough. A buyer’s agent specialising in houses brings market intelligence, negotiation expertise, and access to off-market properties you won’t find online. At InvestorKit, we help investment buyers secure houses that are actually positioned for genuine growth and strong returns.

Common Mistakes When Buying a House or Apartment in Melbourne

Emotional buying over fundamentals:

Many buyers let emotions drive decisions instead of analysing fundamentals. They buy in trendy suburbs when prices peak. Or they fall in love with how a property looks instead of whether it’s actually a good investment. Others spend way too much on renovations or completely ignore what’s happening with suburban growth.

Chasing yield, ignoring growth:

Another big mistake? Obsessing over rental yield while ignoring capital growth. An apartment yielding 5% but appreciating at 1% annually will get crushed by a house yielding 3.5% but growing at 5% annually. Do the math – capital growth creates wealth. Rental income just helps you hold the property.

Underestimating oversupply:

Oversupply is a real problem that people underestimate. Areas with too many apartment developments face years of flat prices because supply swamps demand. Houses in tightly held suburbs with limited development don’t have that problem.

Doing it all alone:

Finally, so many buyers try to do everything themselves. They skip professional help and attempt to navigate a complex market alone. Usually ends with them overpaying, missing better opportunities, or buying properties that don’t match their investment goals at all.

Conclusion

The decision between buying an apartment vs buying a house in Melbourne ultimately comes down to your objectives. But the evidence clearly favours houses for long-term capital growth and wealth creation. Apartments offer affordability and convenience – no argument there. They just lack the land component and scarcity that drive substantial appreciation over time.

Whether you buy a house or an apartment, it’s important to understand what you’re getting into. At InvestorKit, we’re committed to helping investment buyers secure residential houses that deliver real returns. Our expertise in Melbourne’s market, access to off-market opportunities, and strategic approach to property selection – it all ensures your investment works as hard as you do.

Want to know more about property investment with InvestorKit?